So, you’re looking for auto insurance in Barrie? You landed in the right place!

I can’t wait for my auto quote.

We’ll Do the
Work For You!

Simply fill out the form and we’ll get back to you within 24 hours with a quote.

City Page - get a quote

The average* cost of car insurance in Barrie Ontario is just $186 a month . *


Tell Me More

Rate Reducer

Tell Me More

Instantly see our top 10
rates right on your computer
or Smartphone with our
secure and accurate system.

Save a Bundle

Save a Bundle

Bundle your auto
insurance with a tenants or
home policy to save with multiline discounts.

Same Day Setup

Same Day Setup

Our Excalibur
Defenders can usually get
you all set up with your
policy within the day.

Ontario’s team of
top defenders have your back.

Excalibur Team

Become our next happy customer.


We know all
about our customers’
insurance needs
because we’re from
around here, too!

We know all about our customers’ insurance needs because we’re from around here, too!


Did You Know?

Barrie is an outdoor enthusiast’s paradise, with proximity to Lake Simcoe, the Simcoe County forests, and nearby ski resorts like Horseshoe Valley and Mount St. Louis Moonstone. From hiking and mountain biking to skiing and snowboarding, there’s no shortage of activities for residents and visitors to enjoy.

In terms of cuisine, Barrie offers a diverse range of restaurants, cafes, and eateries to cater to every taste. From trendy bistros and cozy pubs to ethnic cuisine and fine dining establishments, there is something to satisfy every craving in Barrie.

Barrie is a lively cultural center with a thriving arts community. Throughout the year, the city hosts a variety of festivals and events that showcase local talent and creativity, such as the Barrie Waterfront Festival, Barrie Film Festival, and Barrie Dragon Boat Festival.

Beautiful Waterfront

Beautiful Waterfront

Barrie boasts a stunning waterfront along Kempenfelt Bay, a natural harbour on Lake Simcoe. The waterfront is a popular destination for recreational activities such as boating, swimming, fishing, and picnicking, offering breathtaking views year-round.

Barrie Speedway

Motorsports enthusiasts will appreciate Barrie Speedway, a popular racing venue located just outside the city. The Speedway hosts exciting stock car racing events throughout the racing season, attracting fans from across the region.

Barrie NHL Beginnings

The Barrie Colts, a junior ice hockey team, are a source of pride for the city. The team competes in the Ontario Hockey League (OHL) and has produced several NHL players over the years, including Aaron Ekblad and Mark Scheifele.

Frequently Asked Questions

about Insurance in Barrie ON?

What is the average cost of auto insurance in Barrie ON?

The average cost of car insurance in Barrie is just $186 a month*

Who has the cheapest auto insurance in Barrie?

Looking for cheap auto insurance in Barrie? The Excalibur Insurance Group works with over 15 different insurance companies to ensure that we find you the best coverage at the lowest rate. Cheap auto insurance in Barrie is just a phone call away! You can call us at 1-888-298-7343 or get an online quote.

Which auto insurance company is the best in Barrie Ontario?

The best insurance company for you is the one that will go above and beyond to protect you and your family. At Excalibur Insurance, we’re committed to finding insurance solutions for everyone. We refuse to compromise in our quest to improve the insurance experience, by offering online quotes, 24-hour chatbot assistance, along with blogs and videos to answer any insurance question you may have.

Which auto insurance is the best for young drivers in Barrie ON?

The best insurance company for young drivers will depend on your age, gender, convictions, driving history, years of experience, commuting distance, and model of your vehicle. Depending on your answers to these questions, the best insurance company for your young driver will change. If you’re on the hunt for the best premium available, speak to an Excalibur Insurance broker for quotes.