What our customers are saying!


Excalibur Insurance ClintonExcalibur Insurance
4.6 Stars - Based on 50 User Reviews


Excalibur Insurance ExeterExcalibur Insurance
4.7 Stars - Based on 54 User Reviews


Excalibur InsuranceExcalibur Insurance
4.7 Stars - Based on 119 User Reviews


Excalibur InsuranceExcalibur Insurance
4 Stars - Based on 4 User Reviews


Excalibur InsuranceExcalibur Insurance Group Inc
4.8 Stars - Based on 104 User Reviews

Darin SmithDarin Smith

Excalibur has been great to me for many years now always helping me out no matter what situation and Carol Bailey is by far the go to lady. She always has your back and will make sure the right thing is done!

ashley vanrasselashley vanrassel

Dealing with Sarah was so easy and hassle free. She got me the best deal and was great to work with. I don’t know a lot about insurance and she was able to answer all my questions and have everything to me quickly. Definitely will be recommending her to friends and family and will be going back to her with all my insurance needs.

Kendrick blancherKendrick blancher

Dylan Shervill was incredible! He's very knowledgable and consistently went out of his way to help me. Thankfully he was able to save me 50$ a month on my car insurance. Thanks brother!


I used to sell cars at a dealership for a long time and, over the years I have dealt with every insurance company that exists out there so trust me when I say that Excalibur Insurance is the best company you can find. Kelsey Bennewies is the person you want. Very professional and most importantly honest which is very hard to find nowadays!

Cat SmithCat Smith

Using this service and having Kelsey as a broker was truly an amazing and stress free experience. Kelsey found me auto and tenant insurance at $250/mo cheaper than what I was paying with CAA (with no tenant insurance). It was easy, quick and everything was done online. Thanks!

John AndrewsJohn Andrews

Friendly agents, great coverage cost. Agent will respond to messages left promptly. I definitely would refer others to Excalibur

Sheona StevensSheona Stevens

Kelsey was amazing through the whole process of me switching insurance over to excalibur. I will admit I definitely kept her on her toes with purchasing a new vehicle unexpectedly and lots of questions. But she had a new quote over to me and responded to all my emails super quickly! She also used plain language so I knew what to expect with my policy. My rates are cheaper, the people are nice and they sent me a little welcome pack when I joined. I don't know what else I could ask for, would recommend.

Ameer AliAmeer Ali

We wanted to switch insurance companies so we went from Dejardins to Intact with the help of a of a friend who recommended me to Josh. Josh was very keen to help us through the process and was very professional. He helped us get through the paperwork and also explained us the bits that were confusing or not easily understandable. He got us a cheaper quote and also helped us out big time with making the switch as we were paying a lot more at Desjardins. I definitely recommend Josh for not only his professionalism but also how he was very interested in helping us out! 10/10 service!

Carrie PhillipsCarrie Phillips

I was working with a broker named Kelsey she explained everything and I feel worked hard to find us the best rate as we had been with our previous insurance company for 20+ years, she made me feel comfortable making the switch. I would definitely recommend her as a broker. Thanks Carrie phillips

Maeghan LeiskauMaeghan Leiskau

Great team to work with- very friendly and I appreciated the follow-up with calls and emails. To top it off, they found the best rates I’ve ever had!

Stanislav SychevskyiStanislav Sychevskyi

Great customer service! The broker went above and beyond for all the requests I had. Definitely recommend it to anybody. Special thanks to Lane Ferguson who helped me with my insurance. They also sent me a nice amount of goodies along with a thank you letter, so kind :)

AB LopezAB Lopez

Service was impeccable! Kelsey Bennewies was kind, helpful, took the time to explain everything; follow up was amazing and her responses were always fast. She was diligent and made the process very simple. Hopefully we won’t need to file any claims, but we hope that if we do, we will receive the same service level.

Jameela BegumJameela Begum

We were hesitant to deal with Excalibur Insurance for our Auto Insurance until we spoke with Kelsey Bennewies, Account Executive. She is very professional and knowledgeable. Her dealings with us were more than excellent. She got us the best auto insurance rate possible. We will deal with her for all our future insurance requirements. We highly recommend Excalibur Insurance for all insurance requirements.

The RobeThe Robe

I was in a pinch and needed help. I had reached out for a few quotes, but Kelsey Bennewies from Excalibur was the first and friendliest to reach back out.

From the moment I began the process till I signed up, Kelsey was incredible with communication, and getting things done quickly.

They went above and beyond, and truly appreciated all of it.

Kelsey and Excalibur have been amazing, can't recommend more!


If I could rate 10 starts I would!!! Josh was absolutely amazing... he goes above and beyond with his job and helped me through a tough situation. Would recommend to anyone, he is TRULY AMAZING.

Devin BDevin B

Honestly the absolute best. They have made things so much easier then i thought possible! Thank you Nerena!

brittany sbrittany s


I wanted to take some time today to recognize my broker Krista Rose and her substitute Sarah Gingerich when Krista is not in the office. They are both totally awesome and easy to work with. They always makes me feel heard, helped, and cared for. I really appreciate their genuine patience, efficiency and knowledge as I am assisted through any situation. I am so grateful to have such amazing brokers at Excalibur Insurance. Thank you Sarah for your help and attention to me when Krista is away and thank you so much Krista for being so awesome as well.

They both deserve recognition as they provide EXCELLENT customer service and satisfaction.

Best Regards,


To Whom it may concern:

When a person has a valid insurance claim, it is up to a professional Adjuster and Broker to help you and your family through a very stressful situation. In this case I can say that Carol Bailey has gone above and beyond her duties to fight for my family and I. She has continued to not only work for us, but has shown professional sincerity for her clients (my wife and I) and has made sure that all of our information has been addressed and our frustrations have been attendended to. This has been a very stressful situation, but having the right person taking care of you, lets you know that you are not just another number and a burden, but a family that needs help. Carol has been a Godsend to us, and we are grateful that she is our Broker.


Ken and Candy Swanson.

Jason NorrisJason Norris

Kelsey Bennewies At Excalibur was fantastic. Quick and very responsive and dealt with my complex needs. Highly recommend for your insurance needs.

Eleanor KnightEleanor Knight

Experience was great. Had a wonderful agent Lane Ferguson. He took care of us and got us the best rate after searching for weeks. We really appreciate Excalibur Insurance for getting us the best coverage for a great price.

Show MoreShow Less