Defending you
is our honour

Ontario’s Lowest Insurance Rates from Your Trusted Broker

Auto Insurance

Auto Quote

Home Insurance

Home Quote

Auto & Home

Bundling could save you big!

Home & Auto

OR, Just give us a call and speak to an Excalibur Defender

Liked your quote? Here’s what happens next.

By using our Rate Reducer or by filling out a form on our website.

An Excalibur Defender will review the quote and your unique needs, to ensure you have the right coverage.

finalize your policy and get your pink slip

Liked your coverage and your quote? Your Defender will send you the documents – you can even sign right from your phone. After signing, we email you your pink slip. Welcome to the Excalibur Family!

We believe busy people apprechiate options that simplify daily life

Protection for everything!

We’ve got Insurance coverage for all the things you care about.

Auto Insurance

Home Insurance

Farm Insurance

Business Insurance

Cottage Insurance

Contractor Insurance

Travel Trailer Insurance

Life Insurance

Recreational Insurance

Travel Insurance

More Options >

Who says Chivalry is dead?

Our team of Defenders right here in Ontario are waiting to “make this the best call of your day”

Meet Our Team

Justin Damsma

Account Executive

Excalibur Insurance - Clinton Office

Finding coverage to protect your life’s work and won’t cost you the farm feels like pretty honest work to Justin.

book an appt.

Jeff Roy

President & CEO

Sometimes the cheapest insurance is just poor coverage. When you charge more and a customer thanks you – you know you’ve done your best to defend what they care about.

Carol Bailey

Personal Lines

Excalibur Insurance – Wingham Office

What’s the point of working in Ontario if you aren’t going to make it better? 5% of our profits goes back into our communities, and A LOT of volunteered hours, hugs and smiles.

book an appt.

Amanda Wood

Account Manager

Excalibur Insurance – Exeter Office

There aren’t many insurance questions she hasn’t answered in her 15 years in the industry, and she’ll ask them all to ensure your family is protected.

book an appt.

Darlene McCowan

Commercial Lines

Excalibur Insurance - Clinton Office

Darlene may be newer to our Commercial Lines team, but her love of constant learning and infectious positive attitude, means she’ll go above and beyond to find the right coverage for your business.

book an appt.

Dylan Shervill

Account Executive

Excalibur Insurance - London Office

Dylan has knowledge for days, and he’ll use it ensure your assets are protected. He also might help you plan a surprise b-day lunch, cause he’s just that kind of team player.

book an appt.

Jennifer Kramer

Account Manager

Excalibur Insurance - Exeter Office

Accidents might not happen on your timeline – but getting you answers will if Jennifer has anything to do with it. #RespectsYourTime.

book an appt.

Josh Mall

Account Executive

Excalibur Insurance

New to Canada and need help understanding insurance requirements? Josh has an affinity for helping individuals shop the market for best in coverage and premiums.

book an appt.

Kellie Round

Director of First Impressions

Excalibur Insurance - Exeter Office

Our team is only as good as the way we make you feel, and Kellie will have you feeling like a Rockstar. Mind of a Jedi – multitasks like an octopus - and keeps it all running smooth.

book an appt.

Kelsey Bennewies

Personal Lines

Excalibur Insurance - Clinton Office

5 years as “Top Sales Person” means she’s got a competitive streak, which she’ll use to score you the best insurance possible.

book an appt.

Krista Rose

Account Manager

Excalibur Insurance - Mitchell Office

Being new to insurance hasn’t stopped Krista from acing her RBIO (Registered Insurance Broker of Ontario and earning her CAIB 1 (Canadian Accredited Insurance Broker) designation. Perhaps you’d like her to study your coverage?

book an appt.

Leigh Crawford

Account Manager

Excalibur Insurance - Mitchell Office

If you don’t ask the right questions – you’ll never know. During your protection review Leigh will uncover gaps you may not have realized to help maximize your coverage.

book an appt.

Savannah Nigh

Personal Lines

Excalibur Insurance

She believes you deserve her best work. That begins by developing a strong relationship and working to ensure what you value is protected.

book an appt.

Selina Consitt

Account Manager

Excalibur Insurance - Mitchell Office

Your protection review should be more like ordering your custom latte, than a dental exam. Selina’s upbeat personality and knowledge will make her your favourite insurance barista.

book an appt.

We work with over 40 of Canada’s Top Insurers to guarantee you have options.

A few of the reasons we Smile.

Zohair H (ON, Canada)

“Have been dealing with them for over 4 years now. Krista Rose has been great and always quick to respond and get back to you. Keep up the good work.”

Darin S (ON, Canada)

“Excalibur has been great to me for many years now always helping me out no matter what situation and Carol Bailey is by far the go to lady. She always has your back and will make sure the right thing is done!”

TL (ON, Canada)

“Since 2004 I've used Excalibur and I've never once had even 4 star service. It's always a 5 star. Helpful and quickly get me answers and change things whenever needed. Couldn't ask for more! They always put my mind at ease and it much appreciated”

Robert P (ON, Canada)

I was trying to find a better insurance rate and had talked at least 3 other companies/brokers prior to hearing back from Excalibur. Kelsey just laid it all out like I wanted to hear it and within 5 minutes I knew I'd be putting my business in their hands.

Melissa B (ON, Canada)

“Thank you Selina for your fabulous customer service. She went above and beyond (compared to other places I’ve contacted) to find a coverage for my truck and horse/livestock trailer at a fabulous price!”

Patrick H (ON, Canada)

“Dylan was very professional and warmly answered all my questions. He quickly got things rolling and made appropriate suggestions on some under-insured areas that I wasn't aware of.”

Millie A (ON, Canada)

“Josh, our agent, worked miracles and was able to give us a quote and options on how to proceed within hours of hearing from us. Before the end of the day, they gave us the best rates out of all the insurance companies that I talked to and received wonderful service.”

Pat S (ON, Canada)

“Was your broker easy to talk to?Jamie-Lynne was amazing. Very informative, helpful and a pleasure to talk to. Do you feel well protected? Very much so. Like a Knight in Shining Armour. Would you refer a friend to Excalibur? Absolutely”

Marein E (ON, Canada)

“The attitude and level of service rendered by Kelsey was remarkable. I’m glad I made that call. She gave me a level of unbiased advise, which is rather uncommon these days. I would highly recommend Excalibur.”

Paris A (ON, Canada)

“I contacted Excalibur for a quote and spoke with a Lane Ferguson. He was nothing short of excellent in his knowledge and advice regarding the renewal of our insurance for home and auto. This was a refreshing experience and we are moving our coverage to Excalibur Insurance.”

Esthera F (ON, Canada)

“My husband and I were in a rush to change our insurance, we spoke with Justin and he was a great help. After reviewing costs for multiple insurance companies, Excalibur was able to offer a much better rate than others.”

Rate Reducer™

Get your 10 Lowest Auto Rates

Get your 10 Lowest Home Rates

You’re in the driver seat with Rate Reducer. We show our hand on the coverage options available and let you Compare your 10 lowest auto or home insurance rates in minutes with our self serve quote tool.

If you see an option you like – reach out.

Free Protection Checkup

with every quote & renewal

We look for potential blind spots. We know, everyone wants cheap insurance, but our job is to protect you from assumptions, unknowns and industry change with our free comprehensive review of your needs.

Get a Protection Checkup