Gore Mutual

Car & Home Insurance Reviews

From your Excalibur Insurance Broker

Who is Gore Mutual Insurance Company?

In 1839, Gore Mutual wrote their first insurance policy in Brantford, Ontario. Although they are the oldest property and casualty insurer in Canada, Gore Mutual has continuously evolved – adopting new technology and insurance coverage solutions. Gore Mutual’s foundation of financial strength has withstood over 180 years in the industry thanks to its ability to continually revitalize its business model, while still holding true to its initial values and reflecting its ambition to scale as a national insurer driven by a sole purpose to deliver outstanding insurance products.

Insurance Coverage Offered by Gore Mutual


Auto Insurance

Gore Mutual offers a variety of coverage options to protect your automobile, including accident repairs, injury to others, theft and vandalism, medical bills, legal fees if you are sued, and rental car coverage. They have coverage for a range of vehicle types, including:

  • Cars
  • SUVs
  • Collector & Antique Vehicles
  • Snowmobiles
  • ATVs
  • Campers & Motorhomes
  • Boats & Jet Skis


Property & Home Insurance

Gore Mutual understands that your home isn’t just your largest investment; it’s also your sanctuary. A standard insurance policy from Gore Mutual will cover damage or loss to your home or property, personal belongings, or detached structures (detached garage, shed, stable, and gazebo). They also offer additional coverages for people who get hurt on your property, identity theft, and living accommodations after a loss. They have coverage for a range of property types, including:

  • Home
  • Condo
  • Tenants
  • Cottage
  • Landlord


Commercial Insurance

Commercial Insurance can protect your business against unexpected losses such as property damage, errors and omissions, injuries to customers, hacking and data breach protection, equipment breakdown, business vehicles (including fleets and garages), as well as legal and public relations help when things go wrong. They have coverage for a range of business types, including:

  • Business Professionals & Consultants
  • Contractors
  • Manufacturing
  • Wholesale
  • Commercial Auto, including Fleets & Garages


Specialty Insurance Services

Thanks to nearly 200 years of experience in the industry, Gore has plenty of experience with understanding that not everyone’s circumstances look the same. As such, Gore Mutual Insurance Company provides a number of specialty insurance products and services to help you better understand your policy and coverage.

  • ClaimCare –
    Gore Mutual understands that you don’t make an insurance claim every day, so why are you expected to know how the process works? They’ve created a step-by-step guide to help you through the claims process. The program offers several features – at no additional cost to you!
  • Right Away Pledge:
    Same day response to all customers’ claims.
  • Dedicated ClaimCare Advisors:
    Available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. When you need to make a claim, you will be assigned a ClaimCare Advisor to guide you through the entire process, so there are no surprises.
  • ClaimCare Tracker:
    The ClaimCare Tracker provides you with regular updates regarding your claim, so that you and your broker are always in the loop.
  • ClaimCare Concierge:
    If your ClaimCare Advisor is on the phone with another customer, the ClaimCare Concierge can provide you with immediate answers to your questions.
  • Certified ClaimCare Network:
    The Certified ClaimCare Network is responsible for helping you repair or rebuild after a loss. Gore Mutual ensures that only trusted experts who meet their high standards are tasked with repairing your car or home after a loss.
  • ClaimCare Mobile Response Team:
    When major disasters happen, the Mobile Response Team is on the ground, helping to provide emergency food and shelter to those in need.

Reviews from a few of Excalibur’s Happy Clients.

Contact Gore Mutual in Ontario

Your Excalibur Insurance broker should always be your first point of contact in the event of an emergency, as well as when you need to make changes to your policy or payment information. However, if you need to contact your insurance provider directly, you can reach them at:

Head Office:

252 Dundas Street North (P.O. Box 70)
Cambridge, Ontario, N1R 5T3

Phone: 800-265-8600
Local Phone: 519-623-1910
Fax: 1-800-601-9773

If you need to report a 24/7 emergency claim, you can get in touch with Gore Mutual Insurance Company directly at 1-844-974-GORE (4673). No matter how you choose to report your claim, know that Gore is prepared to help you through the process.

Learn more about our other insurance partners